What do you think of the boycott?
Jeong Ye-Seul Reporter
In October 2022, an incident at the Pyeongtaek plant led to a consumer boycott. Angered by the tyranny of SPC Group's involvement in repeated industrial disasters, consumers boycotted the company's products. More than half a year later, we took a look at the current state of the boycott and the thoughts of students at Gangneung Wonju University.
Nowadays, many students have forgotten about the SPC boycott. The students said that they participated in the boycott then because of social views and individual thoughts about the SPC Group, but now honestly they don't have any thoughts about the group, and tend to forget about the incident. They also consume products without worrying about the boycott. Overall, the students showed no interest in what the SPC Group has done since then and how the working environment has changed. The sales of Samlip Bakery, one of the group’s subsidiaries, increased 18.9% year-on-year to 204.1 billion won in the first quarter of this year. The sales of the group show that this phenomenon is not limited to our school, but to society as a whole.
Some students joined the boycott because of the social atmosphere, others joined the boycott for the sake of the individual value consumption, and others joined the boycott because they were angry about the group’s unethical behavior.
As the boycott lasted, some students were told that the number of visitors to the stores of the SPC Group subsidiaries would naturally decrease as their image declined. Others said that they had found replacements. But most of the students said that they didn't care about the boycott anymore and would just go to the SPC Group's stores. In the end, the boycott and the actions of the SPC Group will be forgotten in people's memories.
There are two opinions: that the boycott itself should continue, and that the boycott is the wrong way to go. Students who support the former think that the boycott is one of the ways to express consumers’ opinions. They believe that this makes them socially responsible for the unethical behavior of an enterprise. However, they said, “it is regrettable that it is just a trend, such as an issue caused by Korean mass sentiment.” The boycott of the SPC Group was just one of the issues that came to mind for a while, just like the boycott of Japanese products in the past. They said that it takes constant attention to solve social problems, and one of the solutions is to continue the boycott.
The students oppose the boycott itself because of other side effects: some people are being targeted by the boycott. The main targets are self-employed people who run franchise shops of the SPC subsidiaries. According to social justice, they had to share the SPC’s responsibility and the damage was not small. They said that the public should not share responsibility for enterprises, and that consumers should have other ways of pointing out the unethical behaviour of enterprises, not boycotts.
In this regard, Ahn Woo-chul, a professor of international trade at Gangneung Wonju National University, said, "It is not easy to reduce the number of innocent victims. But efforts can be made.
There is a way through cooperation between the National Assembly and consumer organizations. In order to prevent ordinary victims, in the standard contract of the relevant commercial law, the enterprises should include a "franchise special contract" between companies and franchise owners, which guarantees the loss of sales caused by the enterprise’s unethical behavior or worsening market conditions due to serious accidents.
It is necessary to make sure that the system is complemented by continuous advocacy from organizations that protect consumer rights, such as the Korea Consumer Agency".
He said, “We need to reconsider the current state of the boycott, so as not to create innocent victims.” Businesses and consumers must understand and respect one another, so that enterprises and consumers can interact and society can evolve, rather than stagnate by the boycott.